India’s R&D Crossroads: Private Sector Investment Key to Avoiding Middle-Income Trap
India has reached a crucial juncture in its economic journey, where raising expenditure on research and development (R&D) is essential to transition from middle-income status to a developed economy.
What Happened
According to an analysis by leadership at The Convergence Foundation, India’s research landscape has historically been anchored by the public sector. However, historical economic data indicates that economies that successfully leaped to high-income status without relying on natural resources—such as Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan—significantly scaled up research spending when their income levels matched where India stands today. Conversely, economies like Brazil, South Africa, and Thailand did not maintain such intensity and remain in the middle-income trap. Out of 142 middle-income economies assessed since 1990, only 34 have reached high-income status, while 108 remain stuck.
A notable historical benchmark is China in 2007, which had a per-capita GDP of $2,700—comparable to India’s current level. At that time, China’s R&D intensity stood at 1.49 percent of GDP. Between 2007 and 2024, China’s private-sector R&D expanded by more than 10 times while its overall GDP grew 5.5-fold, demonstrating that corporate investment drove growth rather than merely following it.
Key Highlights
- Expenditure Milestones: To meet the Viksit Bharat vision, India needs to reach an R&D investment level of 1.3 percent of GDP by 2030 (with 60 percent funded by industry) and 2 percent of GDP by 2035 (with corporate contributions reaching 70 percent).
- Government Spending: Public R&D outlays need to expand from approximately 0.4 percent of GDP today to 0.5 percent by 2030, and eventually 0.6 percent by 2035.
- Funding Distribution: Three entities—the Defence Research & Development Organisation (DRDO), the Department of Space (DOS), and the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE)—presently account for over 60 percent of central scientific funding, largely within internal laboratories.
- Higher Education Deficit: Higher education institutes receive only 12.6 percent of India’s R&D allocations, despite being the pipeline for foundational research. The analysis recommends raising this allocation to 15–20 percent.
- Policy Impediments: Industry-focused incentives have faced setbacks, including the 2016 rollback of the weighted tax deduction for R&D spending, punitive goods and services tax (GST) treatment on inputs, and an unclear framework for intellectual property (IP) ownership on state-funded research.
- Commercial Success Models: Selected private firms demonstrate viability, such as Glenmark committing $1 billion over a decade into an antibody platform (producing ISB 2001, licensed to AbbVie in 2025 for up to $1.9 billion), and Skyroot Aerospace developing the Vikram-1 orbital rocket, pushing the company’s valuation past $1.1 billion.
Why This Matters
R&D intensity is considered the mechanism through which economies reach the frontier rather than a mere consequence of wealth. As trade pacts expand market access and tariff walls decrease, domestic businesses must compete internationally through proprietary technology. Current government initiatives, such as the Anusandhan National Research Fund (ANRF) and the Research, Development and Innovation Fund (RDIF), have begun providing early-stage risk capital, but sustained growth requires pairing incentives with advance market procurement commitments and private risk-taking.
What to Watch Next
Policy progress will hinge on whether government support shifts toward long-term national technology missions with matched private capital, rather than fragmented grants. Observers will also look for potential reforms regarding R&D tax deductions, GST relief on research inputs, and clear ownership rights for publicly funded intellectual property.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the targeted R&D expenditure levels for India?
The proposed trajectory aims for overall R&D spending to hit 1.3 percent of GDP by 2030 (with a 60 percent industry share) and 2 percent of GDP by 2035 (with industry contributing 70 percent).
Which sectors receive the bulk of India’s central science budget?
More than 60 percent of central scientific spending is concentrated across the Defence Research & Development Organisation (DRDO), the Department of Space (DOS), and the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE).
What challenges do private Indian firms face regarding R&D policy?
Key hurdles include the withdrawal of the weighted tax deduction for research in 2016, unfavorable GST treatment on research inputs, and the lack of a clear intellectual property framework for research conducted with public capital.
Source: Business Standard (Analysis by The Convergence Foundation)
