Deepathoon row: Tamil Nadu files a review plea in Supreme Court against Thirupparankundram order

On November 20, a Division Bench headed by Justice Aravind Kumar allowed the lighting of the lamp, as a restricted and one-off measure, on the deepathoon at the Thirupparankundram Hill on Karthigai Deepam day. File photo
Forty-eight hours before the lighting of the lamp at the deepathoon on Karthigai Deepam day on November 24, the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious & Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) department filed a review of the Supreme Court’s interim order allowing the “one-time limited arrangement”.
The HR&CE Commissioner argued that while the Supreme Court had stayed the Madras High Court’s January 6 direction to the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy Temple Devasthanam to light the Karthigai Deepam on the Deepathoon located near a dargah on the summit of the hill, it had, in the same breath, allowed the lamp to be lit on the very same stone pillar on November 24, terming it a “limited one-time arrangement”, which would not be considered a precedent or a judicial recognition of a vested right.
The State’s review petition said this specific portion of the top court’s November 20 order was an “error apparent on the face of the record”.
The HR&CE Department clarified that it was not seeking a review of the parts of the November 20 order allowing the State’s appeal against the January 6 High Court judgment, nor was it against the grant of stay on the findings arrived at by the High Court.
Natural consequence
The review petition said the natural consequence of the November 20 stay by the top court would be that the Karthigai Deepam would be lit at the traditional place, namely the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple. A stay of the High Court order would mean a return to this “long and unbroken usage”, the State submitted.
The position should have remained unchanged as the top court had not recorded any prima facie finding of fact, right or customary religious observance to back the claim to light the lamp on the stone pillar, the State said.
“When no right is recognised prima facie, a mandatory positive direction altering the existing position on the ground lacks a judicial foundation,” it argued.
The review petition said nothing would have changed on the ground if the lamp had not been lit at the stone pillar this year. If permission had been withheld, no one would have been denied the festival. The Karthigai Deepam would have been lit at the traditional place. In case the asserted claim of the Hindu parties eventually succeeded in the top court, it would have been given full effect in the succeeding years, it added.
Long-standing position
However, with the grant of this permission, the HR&CE Department said, “a long-standing position is altered once and for all at a site in close proximity to the dargah on the basis of a claim that is yet to be established”.
The first course would have preserved the rights of all the parties; the second one had extinguished the rights of one of them before trial, the State contended in the review plea.
‘Contrary to HR&CE Act’
The State said the interim order of November 20 was contrary to the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959, which obliged the trustees to administer the institution in accordance with the binding usages and customs.
Elaborate safeguards given by the Supreme Court with regard to the lighting of the lamp on November 24 and extensive clarifications that the order would not be a precedent, nor would it be considered a recognition of an established religious practice, “cannot undo the factual consequence” of the break in traditional practice done under the very authority of the Supreme Court, the State said.
The review jurisdiction is a rare remedy, and not to be used as an appeal in disguise or as an opportunity to re-argue the case on merits. The parties seeking a review of a Supreme Court decision must prove the decision was erroneous on the face of the record. The party urging a re-look of the court order must show that the findings were a result of a factual misconception or had ignored binding judicial precedents or violated a statutory mandate.
The review petition had been placed before the same Bench that had passed the decision under question. It is usually examined in chambers by circulation.
On November 20, a Supreme Court Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi allowed the lighting of the lamp, as a restricted and one-off measure, on the Deepathoon. The November 20 order repeatedly made it clear that this interim order allowing the lighting of the lamp on the Deepathoon would not give any vested, enforceable right or entitlement to anyone.
The top court had imposed a series of restrictions while directing that the Devasthanam would exclusively decide the members of the team that would light the lamp.
Meanwhile, the Federation of Islamic Organisations and Political Parties on Sunday welcomed the government’s decision to file a review petition in the Supreme Court against its interim order.
The Federation urged the Tamil Nadu government to ensure that the usual practice of lighting the lamp is followed this year too, and that permission is granted to light it only at the customary spot near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple.
Published – November 22, 2026 03:20 pm IST
Source: www.thehindu.com
