Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi reveal how they bypassed logic in Aamir Khan’s 3 Idiots and got away with it: “It’ll NOT pass any screenwriting class…there’s a tremendous logical issue”
Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi, in a conversation with Komal Nahta, spoke about the importance of logic in film writing and the extent to which filmmakers can take cinematic liberties. They also made an interesting observation about 3 Idiots (2009) while explaining their point of view.

Abhijat Joshi said, “If the audience feels something is illogical, it won’t work at all. (But) you can take liberty with logic, and we have done it many times. I’ll give you the example of 3 Idiots. In one day, they get the news of Rancho’s (Aamir Khan) whereabouts, and the same day, Shamaldas Chanchad dies. And on that very day, Pia (Kareena Kapoor Khan) is also getting married! Look at the coincidences. It’ll not pass any screenwriting class. They’ll say, ‘There are too many coincidences’. So, there’s a tremendous logical issue. But I don’t have any reservations about taking liberties with it.”
He further observed, “People must have seen 3 Idiots countless times. Yet, they never thought of this aspect.”
Rajkumar Hirani explained, “Logic is extremely important, especially in certain kinds of cinema. There are some films in which it’s okay if there’s no logic. You can take the slapstick comedy route and make people laugh. In other kinds of cinema, you can take cinematic liberty, provided you don’t get caught! If the audience feels ‘Yaar, aisa ho nahin sakta’, then you’ve lost the plot. Every film will take liberties and bypass logic.”
But does the rule change when it comes to making biopics or films based on real-life events? Abhijat explained, “Then you need to be careful. I am not saying that what I am depicting on screen is 100% what happened. But it has to be 70-80% accurate.”
Rajkumar Hirani continued, “If you look at a film like Gandhi (1982), there may be some changes in the timeline.” He explained that adhering strictly to the actual chronology of events could make it difficult to present the story dramatically. “It’ll become boring. So, you take certain liberties to fit it into the cinematic format.”
Abhijat Joshi raised laughs as he opined, “If it’s a biopic, the values should be intact. Like in Gandhi, you can’t show that the British were not ruling over us! We can’t say that we called the British on a contractual basis ki ‘Bhaiyya, Gateway of India bana ke jao, Lutyens’ Delhi bana ke jao. Humne unko 150 saal import kiya tha. Their work got completed and they left’! You can’t do that. And when somebody does that, my blood boils (laughs). And this does happen!”
The post Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi reveal how they bypassed logic in Aamir Khan’s 3 Idiots and got away with it: “It’ll NOT pass any screenwriting class…there’s a tremendous logical issue” appeared first on Bollywood Hungama.
